Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Sunday, November 15, 2009
7- Hawthorne's Stories (final)
Nathaniel Hawthorne's short stories, "Rappacini's Daughter" and "Artist of the Beautiful", are very similar in the areas of characters, the theme of science, and the metaphor of touching.
Several characters in "Rappaccini's Daughter" and "The Artist of the Beautiful" can be compared to each other. Most notable among them are Rappaccini himself and Peter Hovenden. Both of these men are older and extremely cynical and difficult to be around. Rappacini sees science as being more important than people and even essentially makes his own daughter into a weapon regardless of how she might feel about it. Hovenden has a better relationship with his own daughter, but he is still very hard to get along with, especially for his former apprentice.
There are also several similarities between Annie from "The Artist of the Beautiful" and Beatrice from "Rappaccini's Daughter"-- both are young, beautiful, vivacious women. Each also serves as a love interest for their story's leading character, though neither relationship works out due to the men's failings-- Owen is too timid and sensitive to handle being in a relationship, while Giovanni does not care for Beatrice enough to keep from lashing out at her when he realizes what her father has done to him.
Both stories also deal with science and nature. In "The Artist of the Beautiful" Owen blends science and nature to create the mechanical butterfly from his own spirit, while in "Rappaccini's Daughter" Rappaccini manages to create poisonous plants that infect both Beatrice and Giovanni.
The metaphor that the stories have in common is the power of touch. Owen's experiment in "The Artist of the Beautiful" is so sensitive that the slightest touch destroys months of work. Once the butterfly is made, its ability to live is aided or hindered by the spirit of the person it touches. When it alights on the finger of someone who is warmer and open to its magic, such as Annie, the butterfly is brighter and shows more life; when it lands on the cynical Hovenden, it immediately begins to die; and, when the child grasps it too tightly the butterfly, is utterly destroyed. In "Rappaccini's Daughter" Beatrice cannot touch Giovanni because of her poisonous nature. The one time that she does, it leaves behind a handprint-shaped purple burn.
Several characters in "Rappaccini's Daughter" and "The Artist of the Beautiful" can be compared to each other. Most notable among them are Rappaccini himself and Peter Hovenden. Both of these men are older and extremely cynical and difficult to be around. Rappacini sees science as being more important than people and even essentially makes his own daughter into a weapon regardless of how she might feel about it. Hovenden has a better relationship with his own daughter, but he is still very hard to get along with, especially for his former apprentice.
There are also several similarities between Annie from "The Artist of the Beautiful" and Beatrice from "Rappaccini's Daughter"-- both are young, beautiful, vivacious women. Each also serves as a love interest for their story's leading character, though neither relationship works out due to the men's failings-- Owen is too timid and sensitive to handle being in a relationship, while Giovanni does not care for Beatrice enough to keep from lashing out at her when he realizes what her father has done to him.
Both stories also deal with science and nature. In "The Artist of the Beautiful" Owen blends science and nature to create the mechanical butterfly from his own spirit, while in "Rappaccini's Daughter" Rappaccini manages to create poisonous plants that infect both Beatrice and Giovanni.
The metaphor that the stories have in common is the power of touch. Owen's experiment in "The Artist of the Beautiful" is so sensitive that the slightest touch destroys months of work. Once the butterfly is made, its ability to live is aided or hindered by the spirit of the person it touches. When it alights on the finger of someone who is warmer and open to its magic, such as Annie, the butterfly is brighter and shows more life; when it lands on the cynical Hovenden, it immediately begins to die; and, when the child grasps it too tightly the butterfly, is utterly destroyed. In "Rappaccini's Daughter" Beatrice cannot touch Giovanni because of her poisonous nature. The one time that she does, it leaves behind a handprint-shaped purple burn.
Thesis and Points
Thesis: In "Little Women" and its sequels, Louisa May Alcott's characters Meg and Beth share the same fates as their real life counterparts, but Amy's life takes a different path than her real life counterpart's did. This could be because Alcott and May's relationship was more combative than Alcott's relationships with either of her other sisters.
Points:
- Meg's marriage is very similar to Anna's, minus a few details about her children
- Beth has the same illness and dies under the same circumstances as Lizzie did
- Amy lives to raise her daughter, but May died shortly after her daughter was born
- Alcott expresses envy of May in several different blog entries, seems to feel more responsible for her than for her other sisters.
Points:
- Meg's marriage is very similar to Anna's, minus a few details about her children
- Beth has the same illness and dies under the same circumstances as Lizzie did
- Amy lives to raise her daughter, but May died shortly after her daughter was born
- Alcott expresses envy of May in several different blog entries, seems to feel more responsible for her than for her other sisters.
Sunday, November 8, 2009
4- Frederick Douglass (final)
Students everywhere are told about the importance of education, though few probably understand what this truly means until they read or hear about someone whose life is changed thanks to education. Frederick Douglass is an example about how someone's entire life can change thanks to learning something that now seems as simple as reading.
Douglass first begins to learn to read when his mistress teaches him the alphabet. Her husband catches her doing this and explains to her why he believes it to be a bad idea to educate slaves- that it would "spoil" slaves and make them "forever unfit" and "unmanageable", that "if you give [him] an inch, he will take an ell." (1536) When Douglass overhears this speech, it makes him begin to question his status and whether it is acceptable for him to be a slave.
During the next seven years he continues to teach himself to read, despite his mistress's newfound determination to keep him from learning anything. He does this by tricking the white boys in his neighborhood to teach him to read. While he ran errands, he would take his workbook and some food. He would trade the children food for reading lessons.
After spending time in a ship-yard and watching the workmen make abbreviations for where they were to put their timber, he realizes that he should learn to write as well. He learns to write four letters and from there he once again uses the boys he knows to teach him to write. This time he challenges them to see if they know more than he does and lets them show off their knowledge, learning from them in the process.
As Douglass learns to read and write, he is able to read arguments against slavery and denunciations of it. The more he reads, the more he realizes how terrible slavery is and that he deserves to be free. These are opinions that most slave owners did their best to keep their slaves from forming. By educating himself Douglass was able to learn on his own what so many slaves were unable to grasp.
Douglass first begins to learn to read when his mistress teaches him the alphabet. Her husband catches her doing this and explains to her why he believes it to be a bad idea to educate slaves- that it would "spoil" slaves and make them "forever unfit" and "unmanageable", that "if you give [him] an inch, he will take an ell." (1536) When Douglass overhears this speech, it makes him begin to question his status and whether it is acceptable for him to be a slave.
During the next seven years he continues to teach himself to read, despite his mistress's newfound determination to keep him from learning anything. He does this by tricking the white boys in his neighborhood to teach him to read. While he ran errands, he would take his workbook and some food. He would trade the children food for reading lessons.
After spending time in a ship-yard and watching the workmen make abbreviations for where they were to put their timber, he realizes that he should learn to write as well. He learns to write four letters and from there he once again uses the boys he knows to teach him to write. This time he challenges them to see if they know more than he does and lets them show off their knowledge, learning from them in the process.
As Douglass learns to read and write, he is able to read arguments against slavery and denunciations of it. The more he reads, the more he realizes how terrible slavery is and that he deserves to be free. These are opinions that most slave owners did their best to keep their slaves from forming. By educating himself Douglass was able to learn on his own what so many slaves were unable to grasp.
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
6: The House of Usher (final)
In Edgar Allen Poe's short story, "The Fall of the House of Usher", the narrator spends several weeks with a childhood friend, Roderick Usher. Throughout the story, Usher and the house he lives in are written about almost as a single entity. Indeed, the narrator mentions early in the story that the term the "House of Usher" is used interchangeably to refer to "both the family and the family mansion". (920)
One major way the two are linked is how the look of the house reflects Usher's mental state. As the story begins the narrator describes how the house has always unnerved him. He describes the exterior in dark terms, mentioning its "bleak walls", "vacant eye-like windows" and "decayed trees". (919) There are also several points throughout the story where he describes the interior of the household, and his terms for it are even more depressing: the furniture is "profuse, comfortless, antique and tattered" (921) and the draperies are "dark and tattered" (928). Even touches such as musical instruments that would normally give character to a room "failed to give any vitality to the scene". (921) The readers are left with a strong impression of the house as a gloomy, deteriorated place.
Those words can be used to describe Usher's physical and mental state as well. Usher has a "ghastly pallor" to his skin and "unheeded" silken hair that "floated" around his face (921), "emaciated fingers" (923) and, later, lifeless eyes (928). Usher's illness-- labeled by some as a combination of anxiety, hypochondria and hyperesthesia-- is his defining character trait. His family has a dark history of illness and ill-fortune; as the last of the line, he expects his fate to be similar.
In the end of the story, Usher and the house both perish at the same night. Usher dies when his sister escapes her tomb and bursts into his room, and the narrator flees the house. He looks back in time to see the house split in half and collapse.
One major way the two are linked is how the look of the house reflects Usher's mental state. As the story begins the narrator describes how the house has always unnerved him. He describes the exterior in dark terms, mentioning its "bleak walls", "vacant eye-like windows" and "decayed trees". (919) There are also several points throughout the story where he describes the interior of the household, and his terms for it are even more depressing: the furniture is "profuse, comfortless, antique and tattered" (921) and the draperies are "dark and tattered" (928). Even touches such as musical instruments that would normally give character to a room "failed to give any vitality to the scene". (921) The readers are left with a strong impression of the house as a gloomy, deteriorated place.
Those words can be used to describe Usher's physical and mental state as well. Usher has a "ghastly pallor" to his skin and "unheeded" silken hair that "floated" around his face (921), "emaciated fingers" (923) and, later, lifeless eyes (928). Usher's illness-- labeled by some as a combination of anxiety, hypochondria and hyperesthesia-- is his defining character trait. His family has a dark history of illness and ill-fortune; as the last of the line, he expects his fate to be similar.
In the end of the story, Usher and the house both perish at the same night. Usher dies when his sister escapes her tomb and bursts into his room, and the narrator flees the house. He looks back in time to see the house split in half and collapse.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)